Both vouchers and NCLB as a whole illustrate the flaws of a private market-based system of education. Let's examine vouchers first. Yes, vouchers would allow certain students that would otherwise be unable to attend private schools to afford to do so. These private schools are probably better than the ones the students were attending. The problem is, the number of available placements at private schools is not infinite. What of the children who still cannot attend private school on the voucher system? They are left behind to languish in schools already underfunded. What is more, because school funding is determined by the number of students attending class, these schools will recieve even less money due to the loss of students to private schools. Although some students may be helped by vouchers, is it fair to assist some students at the expense of others?
NCLB has a similar negative effect on students and communities. As Lipman (2008) described, NCLB standards lead to the closing of neighborhood schools, the firing of good teachers, and the displacement of poor and minority communities. The "scientific" precepts of NCLB literacy education are anything but, using flawed studies and incomplete understandings of exactly how children learn to read to promote packaged literacy programs produced by corporations whose owners and investors created NCLB in the first place. Meanwhile, even with these programs schools are failing to meet the unrealistic standards mandated by NCLB. Waiting in the wings for these schools to fail are corporations whose goal is to run these schools for a profit. Who would you rather have educating your children, someone whose first priority is making money, or someone whose first priority is education? It gets worse. Those corporate schools will not be subject to the standards of NCLB because they are not public shools. To put is succinctly, your pyublic school is being shut down and replaced by a private school that probably won't be any better at educating your child. At least with public schools you have a vote on certain things.
I hope reading this makes you scared. Better, I hope reading this makes you mad. Mad enough to write or email your congressman. Let them know that NCLB and vouchers do leave children behind. Let them know that these children are the ones we can least afford to leave behind. Let them know that lack of action on this issue will be measured in your vote. Let them know that "equal standards" are anything but when the children being judged have had anything but an equal start. Let them know for the sake of your children, your neighbors' children, and this country as a whole.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment